{
  "schema": "reference-blade-observations/1",
  "createdAt": "2026-09-25T16:39:39.628850+00:00",
  "sourceVideo": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=23EfsN7vEOA",
  "sourceManifest": "reference-source-frames.json",
  "sourceManifestSha256": "921fd19feb9d1c1cd8f1e58991ffd5ff1e539dab0838b76a8aa59d93774745b9",
  "observer": "Codex visual source inspection",
  "method": "All eight source JPEGs were viewed directly with view_image before annotating. Anatomical left/right follows the source body/leg silhouette; existing manual observation side identities were cross-checked where legs overlap, never model projections. Sparse approximate 2D metal-blade endpoint observations, not automatic tracking. No source image was generated or edited.",
  "scope": "Added solely to diagnose blade-axis agreement in the ankle-DOF comparison. Selection was not random and includes a clear known lunge. This is not an independent population-level accuracy test. Any use for model selection makes it a development diagnostic.",
  "limitations": [
    "Joint/boot landmarks cannot identify blade yaw without visible blade direction.",
    "Boot toe, toe pick, blade front and ankle are different landmarks. Coordinates here denote approximate metal rail tail and front ends, not toe-pick tips.",
    "Camera projection, motion blur and foreshortening prevent reliable 3D ankle yaw estimates from these endpoints.",
    "Confidence is an ordinal visual judgement, not a calibrated probability.",
    "No observed transverse ankle range or ice-boot constraint is inferred.",
    "Only two of sixteen blade axes, both at 129.20 seconds, pass the visual-quality threshold of 0.65. Three additional tentative axes remain excluded from the primary metric.",
    "Missing points are null with zero confidence; never substitute (0,0)."
  ],
  "primaryDiagnosticConfidenceThreshold": 0.65,
  "frames": [
    {
      "time": 122.0,
      "nominalSourceSeconds": 122.0,
      "capturedMediaTime": null,
      "timestampUncertaintySeconds": null,
      "timestampProvenance": "Paused browser screenshots; nominal 25 fps UI frame stepping. Timestamps from visible media element.",
      "image": "research-assets/reference-frames/122.00.jpg",
      "imageSize": [
        1200,
        654
      ],
      "imageSha256": "98f520ccd2ca3271c4a5e76cb10660ac25dfbc0672c55a54311bc8b89244be5b",
      "sourceScreenshotSha256": "777217c9566533b43f7bb1ba2a61d066943137750fbbc849bac958d59c8facc7",
      "sourceNormalization": {
        "screenshotSize": [
          1730,
          1305
        ],
        "publishedCrop": [
          16,
          56,
          1200,
          654
        ]
      },
      "annotationCoordinates": {
        "origin": "top-left of published image",
        "x": "right",
        "y": "down",
        "units": "pixels",
        "additionalCrop": null,
        "oldAnnotationOffsetNotApplied": [
          16,
          56
        ]
      },
      "feet": {
        "left": {
          "anatomicalSide": "left",
          "bladeTail": {
            "xy": null,
            "confidence": 0,
            "visibility": "end-on / blur"
          },
          "bladeFront": {
            "xy": null,
            "confidence": 0,
            "visibility": "end-on / blur"
          },
          "endpointUncertaintyPx": null,
          "useForPrimaryBladeAxisDiagnostic": false,
          "contact": "not independently classified from this still frame",
          "note": "正面偏側滑；左腳受透視縮短、兩刀細節與冰面/黑靴混合，無法可靠分出實際刀尾及刀前端。"
        },
        "right": {
          "anatomicalSide": "right",
          "bladeTail": {
            "xy": null,
            "confidence": 0,
            "visibility": "blur"
          },
          "bladeFront": {
            "xy": null,
            "confidence": 0,
            "visibility": "blur"
          },
          "endpointUncertaintyPx": null,
          "useForPrimaryBladeAxisDiagnostic": false,
          "contact": "not independently classified from this still frame",
          "note": "正面偏側滑；左腳受透視縮短、兩刀細節與冰面/黑靴混合，無法可靠分出實際刀尾及刀前端。"
        }
      },
      "timestampUncertaintyNote": "Legacy manifest reports nominal 25 fps UI stepping but does not record a measured per-frame presentation uncertainty; do not assume exact decoded-frame time."
    },
    {
      "time": 123.2,
      "nominalSourceSeconds": 123.2,
      "capturedMediaTime": null,
      "timestampUncertaintySeconds": null,
      "timestampProvenance": "Paused browser screenshots; nominal 25 fps UI frame stepping. Timestamps from visible media element.",
      "image": "research-assets/reference-frames/123.20.jpg",
      "imageSize": [
        1200,
        654
      ],
      "imageSha256": "867116930b58033b7b65fb3f275d9af71cbdb1c84f74cad592bb535260bbeba8",
      "sourceScreenshotSha256": "066d1bcec8982b59e733182cb8f9cadf235f8cb91363c7e23ca6df5722ede49c",
      "sourceNormalization": {
        "screenshotSize": [
          1730,
          1305
        ],
        "publishedCrop": [
          16,
          56,
          1200,
          654
        ]
      },
      "annotationCoordinates": {
        "origin": "top-left of published image",
        "x": "right",
        "y": "down",
        "units": "pixels",
        "additionalCrop": null,
        "oldAnnotationOffsetNotApplied": [
          16,
          56
        ]
      },
      "feet": {
        "left": {
          "anatomicalSide": "left",
          "bladeTail": {
            "xy": [
              569,
              495
            ],
            "confidence": 0.3,
            "visibility": "suspected / blur"
          },
          "bladeFront": {
            "xy": [
              522,
              522
            ],
            "confidence": 0.3,
            "visibility": "suspected / blur"
          },
          "endpointUncertaintyPx": 7,
          "useForPrimaryBladeAxisDiagnostic": false,
          "contact": "not independently classified from this still frame",
          "note": "左側抬腳刀架有斜向銀白輪廓；刀端受動態模糊且交腿，因此僅低可信候選。右支撐刀被播放器進度列附近遮住。左右身分以原圖連續腿線及既有人工觀測交叉核對，未參考模型。"
        },
        "right": {
          "anatomicalSide": "right",
          "bladeTail": {
            "xy": null,
            "confidence": 0,
            "visibility": "occluded by player UI / end-on"
          },
          "bladeFront": {
            "xy": null,
            "confidence": 0,
            "visibility": "occluded by player UI / end-on"
          },
          "endpointUncertaintyPx": null,
          "useForPrimaryBladeAxisDiagnostic": false,
          "contact": "not independently classified from this still frame",
          "note": "左側抬腳刀架有斜向銀白輪廓；刀端受動態模糊且交腿，因此僅低可信候選。右支撐刀被播放器進度列附近遮住。左右身分以原圖連續腿線及既有人工觀測交叉核對，未參考模型。"
        }
      },
      "timestampUncertaintyNote": "Legacy manifest reports nominal 25 fps UI stepping but does not record a measured per-frame presentation uncertainty; do not assume exact decoded-frame time."
    },
    {
      "time": 124.4,
      "nominalSourceSeconds": 124.4,
      "capturedMediaTime": null,
      "timestampUncertaintySeconds": null,
      "timestampProvenance": "Paused browser screenshots; nominal 25 fps UI frame stepping. Timestamps from visible media element.",
      "image": "research-assets/reference-frames/124.40.jpg",
      "imageSize": [
        1200,
        654
      ],
      "imageSha256": "3be22ba4bfeddd29c6e3879c0c64a8693719c0a0c38a92d7757c47f954283ab0",
      "sourceScreenshotSha256": "1abede9c371449955066c53ac7d871072331c1265406f09068dda6ec292ce583",
      "sourceNormalization": {
        "screenshotSize": [
          1730,
          1305
        ],
        "publishedCrop": [
          16,
          56,
          1200,
          654
        ]
      },
      "annotationCoordinates": {
        "origin": "top-left of published image",
        "x": "right",
        "y": "down",
        "units": "pixels",
        "additionalCrop": null,
        "oldAnnotationOffsetNotApplied": [
          16,
          56
        ]
      },
      "feet": {
        "left": {
          "anatomicalSide": "left",
          "bladeTail": {
            "xy": null,
            "confidence": 0,
            "visibility": "overlap / blur / UI"
          },
          "bladeFront": {
            "xy": null,
            "confidence": 0,
            "visibility": "overlap / blur / UI"
          },
          "endpointUncertaintyPx": null,
          "useForPrimaryBladeAxisDiagnostic": false,
          "contact": "not independently classified from this still frame",
          "note": "兩腳交疊且下方腳接近画面底部；雖見刀架碎影，但刀尾/刀前端與解剖左右的對應不足，不能強行標記。"
        },
        "right": {
          "anatomicalSide": "right",
          "bladeTail": {
            "xy": null,
            "confidence": 0,
            "visibility": "overlap / blur / UI"
          },
          "bladeFront": {
            "xy": null,
            "confidence": 0,
            "visibility": "overlap / blur / UI"
          },
          "endpointUncertaintyPx": null,
          "useForPrimaryBladeAxisDiagnostic": false,
          "contact": "not independently classified from this still frame",
          "note": "兩腳交疊且下方腳接近画面底部；雖見刀架碎影，但刀尾/刀前端與解剖左右的對應不足，不能強行標記。"
        }
      },
      "timestampUncertaintyNote": "Legacy manifest reports nominal 25 fps UI stepping but does not record a measured per-frame presentation uncertainty; do not assume exact decoded-frame time."
    },
    {
      "time": 125.6,
      "nominalSourceSeconds": 125.6,
      "capturedMediaTime": null,
      "timestampUncertaintySeconds": null,
      "timestampProvenance": "Paused browser screenshots; nominal 25 fps UI frame stepping. Timestamps from visible media element.",
      "image": "research-assets/reference-frames/125.60.jpg",
      "imageSize": [
        1200,
        654
      ],
      "imageSha256": "a001c214ef4b799d5d01b51a67394d150fc6c28c6afffe674398b542d3abd961",
      "sourceScreenshotSha256": "f37fcbe4fab3797ba347079584db74d8de0aba51a5db2499ee5171f1f453bad2",
      "sourceNormalization": {
        "screenshotSize": [
          1730,
          1305
        ],
        "publishedCrop": [
          16,
          56,
          1200,
          654
        ]
      },
      "annotationCoordinates": {
        "origin": "top-left of published image",
        "x": "right",
        "y": "down",
        "units": "pixels",
        "additionalCrop": null,
        "oldAnnotationOffsetNotApplied": [
          16,
          56
        ]
      },
      "feet": {
        "left": {
          "anatomicalSide": "left",
          "bladeTail": {
            "xy": null,
            "confidence": 0,
            "visibility": "occluded by boot / end-on"
          },
          "bladeFront": {
            "xy": null,
            "confidence": 0,
            "visibility": "occluded by boot / end-on"
          },
          "endpointUncertaintyPx": null,
          "useForPrimaryBladeAxisDiagnostic": false,
          "contact": "not independently classified from this still frame",
          "note": "背面可辨右腳支撐；右刀短斜段能看見但端點嚴重縮短。左抬腳主要呈現靴底，刀架與黑靴重疊，缺乏可辨識端點。"
        },
        "right": {
          "anatomicalSide": "right",
          "bladeTail": {
            "xy": [
              692,
              488
            ],
            "confidence": 0.3,
            "visibility": "suspected / foreshortened"
          },
          "bladeFront": {
            "xy": [
              715,
              476
            ],
            "confidence": 0.3,
            "visibility": "suspected / foreshortened"
          },
          "endpointUncertaintyPx": 6,
          "useForPrimaryBladeAxisDiagnostic": false,
          "contact": "not independently classified from this still frame",
          "note": "背面可辨右腳支撐；右刀短斜段能看見但端點嚴重縮短。左抬腳主要呈現靴底，刀架與黑靴重疊，缺乏可辨識端點。"
        }
      },
      "timestampUncertaintyNote": "Legacy manifest reports nominal 25 fps UI stepping but does not record a measured per-frame presentation uncertainty; do not assume exact decoded-frame time."
    },
    {
      "time": 129.2,
      "nominalSourceSeconds": 129.2,
      "capturedMediaTime": null,
      "timestampUncertaintySeconds": null,
      "timestampProvenance": "Paused browser screenshots; nominal 25 fps UI frame stepping. Timestamps from visible media element.",
      "image": "research-assets/reference-frames/129.20.jpg",
      "imageSize": [
        1200,
        654
      ],
      "imageSha256": "a32d2fe2ec1fe7ec60722a99e2e39b180248bd8c96ff2d22bc5cadfa21ffe141",
      "sourceScreenshotSha256": "286e1c514ef0493e09ff6af384de68a9934d85e409bd2101eb859081dbc2d94d",
      "sourceNormalization": {
        "screenshotSize": [
          1730,
          1305
        ],
        "publishedCrop": [
          16,
          56,
          1200,
          654
        ]
      },
      "annotationCoordinates": {
        "origin": "top-left of published image",
        "x": "right",
        "y": "down",
        "units": "pixels",
        "additionalCrop": null,
        "oldAnnotationOffsetNotApplied": [
          16,
          56
        ]
      },
      "feet": {
        "left": {
          "anatomicalSide": "left",
          "bladeTail": {
            "xy": [
              825,
              540
            ],
            "confidence": 0.8,
            "visibility": "visible"
          },
          "bladeFront": {
            "xy": [
              837,
              475
            ],
            "confidence": 0.8,
            "visibility": "visible"
          },
          "endpointUncertaintyPx": 4,
          "useForPrimaryBladeAxisDiagnostic": true,
          "contact": "not independently classified from this still frame",
          "note": "面向鏡頭：解剖左腿伸直在畫面右側、靴尖朝上，銀色刀架及刀刃斜直立；右膝彎曲支撑，右刀刃在畫面左側近水平。標的是金屬刀刃端點而非黑色靴尖；左刀接触可能偏刀尾，但此觀測不量測反力。"
        },
        "right": {
          "anatomicalSide": "right",
          "bladeTail": {
            "xy": [
              577,
              547
            ],
            "confidence": 0.85,
            "visibility": "visible"
          },
          "bladeFront": {
            "xy": [
              500,
              544
            ],
            "confidence": 0.85,
            "visibility": "visible"
          },
          "endpointUncertaintyPx": 3,
          "useForPrimaryBladeAxisDiagnostic": true,
          "contact": "not independently classified from this still frame",
          "note": "面向鏡頭：解剖左腿伸直在畫面右側、靴尖朝上，銀色刀架及刀刃斜直立；右膝彎曲支撑，右刀刃在畫面左側近水平。標的是金屬刀刃端點而非黑色靴尖；左刀接触可能偏刀尾，但此觀測不量測反力。"
        }
      },
      "timestampUncertaintyNote": "Legacy manifest reports nominal 25 fps UI stepping but does not record a measured per-frame presentation uncertainty; do not assume exact decoded-frame time."
    },
    {
      "time": 131.6,
      "nominalSourceSeconds": 131.6,
      "capturedMediaTime": null,
      "timestampUncertaintySeconds": null,
      "timestampProvenance": "Paused browser screenshots; nominal 25 fps UI frame stepping. Timestamps from visible media element.",
      "image": "research-assets/reference-frames/131.60.jpg",
      "imageSize": [
        1200,
        654
      ],
      "imageSha256": "9ae9090fa453de4da341f8183287f5d4bd8a066e3f9fb5a027978d7bf8080855",
      "sourceScreenshotSha256": "b6c5b3bc1f935d1666171d7a61f5e902220a8e992ff06db74fc5911e27e386a1",
      "sourceNormalization": {
        "screenshotSize": [
          1730,
          1305
        ],
        "publishedCrop": [
          16,
          56,
          1200,
          654
        ]
      },
      "annotationCoordinates": {
        "origin": "top-left of published image",
        "x": "right",
        "y": "down",
        "units": "pixels",
        "additionalCrop": null,
        "oldAnnotationOffsetNotApplied": [
          16,
          56
        ]
      },
      "feet": {
        "left": {
          "anatomicalSide": "left",
          "bladeTail": {
            "xy": null,
            "confidence": 0,
            "visibility": "overlap / blur"
          },
          "bladeFront": {
            "xy": null,
            "confidence": 0,
            "visibility": "overlap / blur"
          },
          "endpointUncertaintyPx": null,
          "useForPrimaryBladeAxisDiagnostic": false,
          "contact": "not independently classified from this still frame",
          "note": "近腳刀架雖可見近水平亮段，兩腿與靴端交疊、動態模糊使前後端方向及解剖對應無法可靠辨識。"
        },
        "right": {
          "anatomicalSide": "right",
          "bladeTail": {
            "xy": null,
            "confidence": 0,
            "visibility": "overlap / blur"
          },
          "bladeFront": {
            "xy": null,
            "confidence": 0,
            "visibility": "overlap / blur"
          },
          "endpointUncertaintyPx": null,
          "useForPrimaryBladeAxisDiagnostic": false,
          "contact": "not independently classified from this still frame",
          "note": "近腳刀架雖可見近水平亮段，兩腿與靴端交疊、動態模糊使前後端方向及解剖對應無法可靠辨識。"
        }
      },
      "timestampUncertaintyNote": "Legacy manifest reports nominal 25 fps UI stepping but does not record a measured per-frame presentation uncertainty; do not assume exact decoded-frame time."
    },
    {
      "time": 139.4,
      "nominalSourceSeconds": 139.4,
      "capturedMediaTime": 139.399997,
      "timestampUncertaintySeconds": 0.04,
      "timestampProvenance": "Paused browser frame stepping; screenshot after accessibility observation to allow decoded frame presentation; nominal 25 fps, approximately one frame uncertainty.",
      "image": "research-assets/reference-frames/139.40.jpg",
      "imageSize": [
        1200,
        654
      ],
      "imageSha256": "13bc0923be122b010dc9ac143d9140625cd34748a2f5ececf1a8571a5495fba0",
      "sourceScreenshotSha256": "c8e58ee23a55c54b0c476e440f5b44f76c39e35b176c587fbe0bfdb879c3b957",
      "sourceNormalization": {
        "screenshotSize": [
          2314,
          1221
        ],
        "screenshotCrop": {
          "left": 215,
          "top": 56,
          "width": 1872,
          "height": 1053
        },
        "resize": [
          1200,
          675
        ],
        "crop": [
          0,
          21,
          1200,
          654
        ],
        "annotationOffset": [
          16,
          56
        ]
      },
      "annotationCoordinates": {
        "origin": "top-left of published image",
        "x": "right",
        "y": "down",
        "units": "pixels",
        "additionalCrop": null,
        "oldAnnotationOffsetNotApplied": [
          16,
          56
        ]
      },
      "feet": {
        "left": {
          "anatomicalSide": "left",
          "bladeTail": {
            "xy": [
              713,
              494
            ],
            "confidence": 0.4,
            "visibility": "suspected / blur"
          },
          "bladeFront": {
            "xy": [
              672,
              500
            ],
            "confidence": 0.4,
            "visibility": "suspected / blur"
          },
          "endpointUncertaintyPx": 6,
          "useForPrimaryBladeAxisDiagnostic": false,
          "contact": "not independently classified from this still frame",
          "note": "左腳地面支撐，靴尖朝畫面左；刀架在靴底與冰面間僅有短淺輪廓，視為低可信端點。右踢腿刀架呈明顯動態拖影，缺測。"
        },
        "right": {
          "anatomicalSide": "right",
          "bladeTail": {
            "xy": null,
            "confidence": 0,
            "visibility": "motion blur"
          },
          "bladeFront": {
            "xy": null,
            "confidence": 0,
            "visibility": "motion blur"
          },
          "endpointUncertaintyPx": null,
          "useForPrimaryBladeAxisDiagnostic": false,
          "contact": "not independently classified from this still frame",
          "note": "左腳地面支撐，靴尖朝畫面左；刀架在靴底與冰面間僅有短淺輪廓，視為低可信端點。右踢腿刀架呈明顯動態拖影，缺測。"
        }
      },
      "timestampUncertaintyNote": "Source manifest states approximately one 25 fps frame uncertainty; 0.04 seconds is that stated approximation, not an independent timestamp calibration."
    },
    {
      "time": 140.56,
      "nominalSourceSeconds": 140.56,
      "capturedMediaTime": 140.559989,
      "timestampUncertaintySeconds": 0.04,
      "timestampProvenance": "Paused browser frame stepping; screenshot after accessibility observation to allow decoded frame presentation; nominal 25 fps, approximately one frame uncertainty.",
      "image": "research-assets/reference-frames/140.56.jpg",
      "imageSize": [
        1200,
        654
      ],
      "imageSha256": "9a9722954d8b037aa5b7d30f414ff9629bde8f2e57b5fb426745bde464b228ea",
      "sourceScreenshotSha256": "562c972c222c09c1377dcc2ffd5799f61c77db1c1c2b1a26de20fbc946f5eab1",
      "sourceNormalization": {
        "screenshotSize": [
          2314,
          1221
        ],
        "screenshotCrop": {
          "left": 215,
          "top": 56,
          "width": 1872,
          "height": 1053
        },
        "resize": [
          1200,
          675
        ],
        "crop": [
          0,
          21,
          1200,
          654
        ],
        "annotationOffset": [
          16,
          56
        ]
      },
      "annotationCoordinates": {
        "origin": "top-left of published image",
        "x": "right",
        "y": "down",
        "units": "pixels",
        "additionalCrop": null,
        "oldAnnotationOffsetNotApplied": [
          16,
          56
        ]
      },
      "feet": {
        "left": {
          "anatomicalSide": "left",
          "bladeTail": {
            "xy": null,
            "confidence": 0,
            "visibility": "end-on / blur"
          },
          "bladeFront": {
            "xy": null,
            "confidence": 0,
            "visibility": "end-on / blur"
          },
          "endpointUncertaintyPx": null,
          "useForPrimaryBladeAxisDiagnostic": false,
          "contact": "not independently classified from this still frame",
          "note": "正面雙腳離冰，刀軸幾乎朝向鏡頭而極度縮短，只有靴底尖輪廓；不可把靴尖或影子當成完整刀刃軸。"
        },
        "right": {
          "anatomicalSide": "right",
          "bladeTail": {
            "xy": null,
            "confidence": 0,
            "visibility": "end-on / blur"
          },
          "bladeFront": {
            "xy": null,
            "confidence": 0,
            "visibility": "end-on / blur"
          },
          "endpointUncertaintyPx": null,
          "useForPrimaryBladeAxisDiagnostic": false,
          "contact": "not independently classified from this still frame",
          "note": "正面雙腳離冰，刀軸幾乎朝向鏡頭而極度縮短，只有靴底尖輪廓；不可把靴尖或影子當成完整刀刃軸。"
        }
      },
      "timestampUncertaintyNote": "Source manifest states approximately one 25 fps frame uncertainty; 0.04 seconds is that stated approximation, not an independent timestamp calibration."
    }
  ]
}
